Fishing At

Lake Shelbyville

4.0

(8)

66 Catches

Lake Shelbyville is located in Shelby County, Illinois. Download FishAngler to find the best places to fish at Lake Shelbyville. Get local fishing reports with detailed catch information, weather conditions, top baits and more.

Access & Amenities

39.498974, -88.693927

Explore Full Map

Recent Catches At Lake Shelbyville

eli Crosier

2025-07-28

•

Moultrie County, Illinois

Used a cast net and got this sucker.

Species Bluegill

5 likes

Christopher Brewer

2025-07-11

•

Shelby County, Illinois

Species Flathead catfish

Weight 14 lb 14 oz

9 likes • 2 comments

Get Ready

To Fish

with the best fishing app on the planet

Download The App

Chris Taing

2025-06-04

•

Moultrie County, Illinois

Fun day fishing crappie at Shelbyville (4 man limit)

Species White crappie

Weight 1 lb

Gear 1

17 likes • 2 comments

Walter A

2025-05-13

•

Moultrie County, Illinois

Fished Lake Shelbyville this morning and Lake Mattoon in the afternoon. Bite was fairly consistent at both lakes, but they were being crappie. Finicky AF lol.

Species White crappie

24 likes • 2 comments

Jacob Book

2025-03-27

•

Moultrie County, Illinois

Species Channel catfish

6 likes

Jacob Book

2025-03-27

•

Moultrie County, Illinois

Species White catfish

5 likes • 1 comment

Jh Lh

2024-04-24

•

Moultrie County, Illinois

Little river action! IYKYK

Gear 1

9 likes • 1 comment

Alex Looper

2024-04-15

•

Shelby County, Illinois

Species White crappie

Gear 3

7 likes

Get Ready

To Fish

with the best fishing app on the planet

Download The App

Most Caught Fish Species At Lake Shelbyville

Largemouth black bass

Channel catfish

Flathead catfish

Freshwater drum

Smallmouth buffalo

Southern flounder

Popular Fishing Spots Near Lake Shelbyville

Lake Springfield

49.7 mi away • Sangamon County, Illinois

43.9 mi away • De Witt County, Illinois

39.5 mi away • Christian County, Illinois

23.2 mi away • Macon County, Illinois

Lake of the Woods

51 mi away • Lake of the Woods, Illinois

Unnamed / Sarpy St Pond

37.8 mi away • Bear Creek, Illinois

Unnamed / Magnolia Dr Pond

55.7 mi away • St. Joseph, Illinois

River Bend Forest Preserve

48.7 mi away • Mahomet, Illinois

Blue background image

App image

Want to know more about fishing at

Lake Shelbyville?

Download the FishAngler app to get access to advanced fishing maps, local fishing reports & forecasts. Join millions of anglers and get all the intel you need to catch more fish!