Fishing At

Carter Lake Reservoir

4.0
(7)
225 Catches
Carter Lake Reservoir is located in Larimer County, Colorado. Download FishAngler to find the best places to fish at Carter Lake Reservoir. Get local fishing reports with detailed catch information, weather conditions, top baits and more.
Access & Amenities
Public
40.334298, -105.219303

Recent Catches At Carter Lake Reservoir

Mile High Fishing

3 days ago
 • 
Larimer County, Colorado

I was fortunate to spend the day at Carter Lake with my amazing girlfriend and my buddy, who I hadn't seen in about a year. We grilled and chilled and did some fishing from the kayaks. We only caught a couple rainbows but it was an absolutely perfect lake day. ⛰️ 🎣👌

Rainbow trout
6
15 likes

Mile High Fishing

2 weeks ago
 • 
Larimer County, Colorado

First adventure to Carter Lake with the boy's! It was a long day in the kayaks on the water. I think we were there from 7am to 6pm. The bite didn't kick off until about 4pm as afternoon clouds rolled in. The first big Cutbow I hooked up with, twisted my two lines around each other and then wrapped around my phone stand. As I was fighting this swamp donkey, my phone was knocked off it's mount, and straight into the lake. My phone now rests in peace in about 90 feet of water. Worth it. 👌

Cutbow Trout
7
15 likes • 2 comments
App logo
Get Ready
To Fish
with the best fishing app on the planet

Todd Catchagrip

2026-03-09
 • 
Larimer County, Colorado

Hey folks !! Tight lines to y’all. I added this professional wrestling poster for those who have met myself and my daughter over the years. She makes her Professional Wrestling debut April 2, two weeks after her 14th birthday. It’s a PPV on you tube. My daughter is Kayla, her ring name is Allie Knox.

Cutbow Trout
1
43 likes • 3 comments

Eric Holmlund

2026-02-01
 • 
Larimer County, Colorado

Paddled several miles and didn’t see many marks on the sonar. I caught five smaller rainbow trout in the 12-inch range. Not the big fish I was looking for, but they were still fun to catch as they were jigged from 30-40 feet in 50-70 feet of water. I may have caught more fish if I’d spent the afternoon trolling instead of jigging, but I was really hoping to sharpshoot a good sized fish.

Rainbow trout
5
82 likes • 23 comments

Todd Catchagrip

2026-02-14
 • 
Larimer County, Colorado

I have not posted for a while. Troll ass weak cowards behind a keyboard have been keeping me away from social media lately. I’m over that stuff as much as I can. But I truly believe people should be held accountable and punched in the face every once in a while. The world would be better place for sure . I love giving Fish!! sore lips. Wish I could JACK and troll in the mouth.

Cutbow Trout
1
20 likes • 1 comment

Bennett Boothe

2025-12-20
 • 
Larimer County, Colorado

One decent fish out of 40.

Cutbow Trout
4
31 likes • 9 comments

Bennett Boothe

2025-12-12
 • 
Larimer County, Colorado

Couple little guys on the jig this morning.

Cutbow Trout
2
27 likes • 6 comments

Bennett Boothe

2025-12-07
 • 
Larimer County, Colorado

Only had an hour to fish on our way home from church camp. They stocked the lake recently and the stockers are a nuisance when bait fishing. We caught at least 20 stockers, but eventually got a couple nice rainbows. All C&R as we are blessed with no space in any of our freezers. Nothing bit the lures today, wasn't for a lack of effort though. God is good!

Rainbow trout
4
22 likes • 5 comments
App logo
Get Ready
To Fish
with the best fishing app on the planet
Blue background image
App image
Want to know more about fishing at
Carter Lake Reservoir?
Download the FishAngler app to get access to advanced fishing maps, local fishing reports & forecasts. Join millions of anglers and get all the intel you need to catch more fish!
Rating App Reviews