Fishing At

Lake Tonetta

No Rating (0)

43 Catches

Lake Tonetta is located in Brewster Hill, New York. Download FishAngler to find the best places to fish at Lake Tonetta. Get local fishing reports with detailed catch information, weather conditions, top baits and more.

41.421158, -73.611059

Explore Full Map

Recent Catches At Lake Tonetta

Capt'n K'nuckles

1 week ago

•

Putnam County, New York

Moon was so bright tonight, had to do a little night fishing. Couldn't get a better pic because he wouldn't stop flopping around! They really fight hard

Species Smallmouth bass

Weight 3 lb

Gear 1

9 likes

Capt'n K'nuckles

2025-07-11

•

Putnam County, New York

Saw a little splash near the lily pads, dropped my lure right on top of him and WHAM! #CatchKing

Species Largemouth black bass

Weight 4 lb 4 oz

Gear 1

15 likes • 4 comments

Get Ready

To Fish

with the best fishing app on the planet

Download The App

Capt'n K'nuckles

2025-05-01

•

Putnam County, New York

Only one I caught this morning, but I'll take it!

Species Largemouth black bass

Weight 4 lb 8 oz

Gear 1

21 likes • 2 comments

Capt'n K'nuckles

2025-04-22

•

Putnam County, New York

Nice haul today, 13 keepers, including thus hog 1.5 lbs, 14"

Species Black crappie

Weight 1 lb 8 oz

Gear 1

8 likes • 1 comment

Capt'n K'nuckles

2025-04-04

•

Putnam County, New York

Lunker Alert! First big bass of the year, just a hair over 4lbs, almost up to my knee. Hopefully a sign of a good season 🤞

Species Largemouth black bass

Weight 4 lb

19 likes • 3 comments

Capt'n K'nuckles

2024-09-17

•

Putnam County, New York

Only my third 4 pounder this year, hence the cheesy smile

Species Largemouth black bass

Weight 4 lb

Gear 1

16 likes • 5 comments

Capt'n K'nuckles

2024-04-23

•

Putnam County, New York

This season is off to a good start, another 4 pounder

Species Largemouth black bass

Weight 4 lb

Gear 1

20 likes

Capt'n K'nuckles

2024-04-17

•

Putnam County, New York

Tied my personal best today, 4lb 12oz

Species Largemouth black bass

Weight 4 lb 12 oz

Gear 1

18 likes • 3 comments

Get Ready

To Fish

with the best fishing app on the planet

Download The App

Most Caught Fish Species At Lake Tonetta

Largemouth black bass

Smallmouth bass

American yellow perch

Popular Fishing Spots Near Lake Tonetta

Long Island Sound

23.5 mi away • Suffolk County, New York

35.1 mi away • Bergen County, New Jersey

37.6 mi away • Bergen County, New Jersey

Hudson River (Lower)

19 mi away • Westchester County, New York

15 mi away • Dutchess County, New York

Kensico Reservoir

21.6 mi away • Westchester County, New York

31.4 mi away • Bronx County, New York

40.7 mi away • Meriden, Connecticut

Blue background image

App image

Want to know more about fishing at

Lake Tonetta?

Download the FishAngler app to get access to advanced fishing maps, local fishing reports & forecasts. Join millions of anglers and get all the intel you need to catch more fish!