Fishing At

Cincinnatus Lake

5.0

(1)

5 Catches

Cincinnatus Lake is located in New York. Download FishAngler to find the best places to fish at Cincinnatus Lake. Get local fishing reports with detailed catch information, weather conditions, top baits and more.

42.427412, -75.865345

Explore Full Map

Recent Catches At Cincinnatus Lake

Tyler Johnson

2026-07-09

•

Cortland County, New York

Species Largemouth black bass

Weight 2 lb 3 oz

Gear 1

10 likes • 1 comment

Tyler Johnson

2026-07-06

•

Cortland County, New York

PB pickeral, might not beat this for awhile

Species Chain pickerel

Gear 1

4 likes

Caleb Jahones

2024-07-09

•

Cortland County, New York

I almost broke the world record crappie today drawing in at 1 foot and 3 inches and 3.6 pounds i cant be more glad i was able to catch something this beautiful and amazing

Species Black crappie

Weight 3 lb 6 oz

Gear 1

19 likes • 4 comments

Get Ready

To Fish

with the best fishing app on the planet

Download The App

Most Caught Fish Species At Cincinnatus Lake

Largemouth black bass

Popular Fishing Spots Near Cincinnatus Lake

Susquehanna River

17.3 mi away • Tioga County, New York

32.6 mi away • Cayuga County, New York

Susquehanna River

18.7 mi away • Otsego County, New York

Cannonsville Reservoir

34.6 mi away • Delaware County, New York

42.4 mi away • Oneida County, New York

45 mi away • Milford, New York

Finch Hollow Nature Center Pond

19.3 mi away • Broome County, New York

34.2 mi away • Onondaga County, New York

Blue background image

App image

Want to know more about fishing at

Cincinnatus Lake?

Download the FishAngler app to get access to advanced fishing maps, local fishing reports & forecasts. Join millions of anglers and get all the intel you need to catch more fish!