Fishing In
Shelter Island, New York
With FishAngler you can discover the best fishing spots in Shelter Island.
Check out the top fish species being caught and learn what baits are the most successful.
Get detailed information on when and where the fish are biting in Shelter Island
and get valuable tips to increase your fishing success.
41.058481,
-72.314234
Recent Catches In Shelter Island, New York
Colleen Murray At Little Peconic Bay
2 weeks ago
•
Suffolk County, New York
Ewe! My Aunts said he cannot come aboard. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
American eel
1
Colleen Murray At Little Peconic Bay
2 weeks ago
•
Suffolk County, New York
I love fishing off the back of my Aunt's boat when it's docked! You catch some many different things in a day.
Northern puffer
2
Colleen Murray At Little Peconic Bay
2 weeks ago
•
Suffolk County, New York
Spot croaker
2
Colleen Murray At Little Peconic Bay
2 weeks ago
•
Suffolk County, New York
Dusky smooth-hound
2
Colleen Murray At Little Peconic Bay
2 weeks ago
•
Suffolk County, New York
Dusky smooth-hound
2
Colleen Murray At Little Peconic Bay
2 weeks ago
•
Suffolk County, New York
Scup
2
Colleen Murray At Little Peconic Bay
2024-07-04
•
Suffolk County, New York
First one off these guys for me!
Spot croaker
1
Colleen Murray At Little Peconic Bay
2024-07-04
•
Suffolk County, New York
Hopped on these guys again today!
Dusky smooth-hound
1
Popular Fishing Spots In Shelter Island, New York
Other Cities Near Shelter Island
Shelter Island
Suffolk County, New York
Shelter Island Heights
Suffolk County, New York
North Haven
Suffolk County, New York
Dering Harbor
Suffolk County, New York
Greenport Homes
Suffolk County, New York
Greenport
Suffolk County, New York
Bay Point
Suffolk County, New York
Alewife Brook Landing
Suffolk County, New York
Want to know more about fishing in or around
Shelter Island?
Download the FishAngler app to get access to advanced fishing maps, local fishing reports & forecasts. Join millions of anglers and get all
the intel you need to catch more fish!
